The Circle Method

 

A geometric representation of solutions of the secular equations for cyclic conjugated polyenes

 

·    A particularly useful (and easy) way of finding the MOs of cyclic conjugated polyenes is the ‘Geometric’ or ‘Circle’ Method. 

·    In this method, a diagram of the polyene is inscribed in a circle of radius 2b. 

·    One apex of the polyene must be at the bottom. 

·    The vertical axis represents energy. 

·    The centre of the circle has an energy a. 

·    The lowest point of the circle corresponds to an energy of (a + 2b).  Note that b is negative, so this is a lower energy than a. 

·    There is a molecular orbital at the energy corresponding to where the corners are situated. 

 

For example: 

3-membered ring (cyclopropenyl radical)

 

 

 

 

________________________________________

 

5-membered ring (cyclopentadienyl anion)

 

 

________________________________________

 

 

6-membered ring (benzene)

 

 

 

This leads on to the concept of aromaticity...